REVIEW: The Thorne Legacy by J. D. Brink

Friday , 31, March 2017 15 Comments

Okay, this one is very nearly non-stop action. It’s straight ahead no-frills military science fiction with alien invaders that are just different enough from the ones in the big movie franchises to keep you guessing. There are space marines. There are starships. There’s enough technobabble to make it all seem real and there’s not so much that it becomes a headache. The is pure, unadulterated entertainment with a hint that there could maybe be something more down the road.

Because this story delivers on the half a dozen things I typically expect authors to accomplish, I’m just going to home in on one aspect of this tale that stands out to me. The title references a family legacy, one that’s facing some serious trouble in the opening chapter:

“Six generations of spacefaring military officers…”
Not the Odysseus lecture again, Thorne thought. The first two ancesters in that proud line were supposedly of the Odysseus subspecies, engineered for space exploration. Even though the characteristic Thorne build hinted at the robust nature of Oddies, Cranston had always assumed that particular claim was dreamed up by his father for pure boasting rights.
The Captain tossed the green jacket to the floor. “And not only are you not an officer, but you’re not even in the System Guard Spatial Corps. Six generations of tradition and family honor, and with you the chain’s been broken. The Thorne legacy, ruined.”

Dad in this case comes off like the drill sergeant from Full Metal Jacket. Reading the exchange… I can’t help but think that it’s been ages since anyone wrote something like this.

Oh, there’s the evil undead hateful creepy monster dad in Iron Fist that drives his son to drink with his constant lectures and meddling. And that’s the thing: any sort of assertive fathering tends to be painted in a bad light these days. The “good” dads…? They’re like Barry Allan’s foster dad raising his “son” to not stand up to bullies and some such. Something like a proud legacy passed from father to son for six generations, though…? You’d practically have to reach all the way back to Jack Williamson’s Legion of Space to find something like that now.

Is it just a matter of times changing, of popular archetypes getting a well deserved rotation…? I could have been persuaded of that once maybe. After all, it’s just entertainment, right? But when the “overbearing jerkwad father berates his son to the point where he goes over the edge and kills his dad” moved from being sort of an outlier and into being some sort of stock trope, I had to wonder if maybe somebody somewhere has some serious daddy issues.

According to author John Van Stry, that is indeed the case:

The men who founded the publishing companies died, and their daughters, who they sent to ivy league schools took over and applied what they were taught there to the industry….

And with the changing of the guard, there has been a shift in the culture along with it– and the composition of the fiction market audience adjusting accordingly:

I write novels with strong male characters and boy do I get a lot of [flack] for it.

I’ve got two more I’ve promised to write in two different series, but after that, I’m thinking of doing what everyone else does and just write strong female characters, really strong, UBER strong. Stronger, smarter, faster, better than all the men, who they constantly show up, and who all worship her.

Because that’s what sells. In droves. Women want it, and at this point the minority of readers who are men are used to it enough, that they’ll still buy it, as long as the story as good.

So men drifted away from reading over the years. This created a very real financial incentive for authors to produce certain types of stories, regardless of the dictates of the big brand editors and publishers. Anyone that failed to go with the flow…? They not only made less money. They were singled out for flack.

This has by now gone on so long and so completely that we are long overdue for a market correction. But really, there’s only so long that an “industry” can stand to tell forty percent of the market place to simply buzz off. Change is coming, but it won’t be from within. The real work of turning things around will be done by the sort of independents and amateurs that wouldn’t have had a place in the old order. Literary barbarians as it were.

Consciously or not, J. D. Brink is a part of that new wave. He’s taking the sort of chances that you won’t see trickling up to the television and movie studios for a long time. And it isn’t some sort of testosterone laden punch to the face, either. It’s just a break from the unending parade of ninety pound girls beating the tar out of three hundred pound dudes. It’s not some aggressive counter-ideology looking for a chance to take the reins of culture. It’s a return of stories featuring tough (but likable) dads that deserve some respect and sons that you’d want to see go out and earn it.

Is that really some sort of earthshaking radical concept…?

Actually, right now in science fiction and fantasy scene… it really is.

15 Comments
  • Hooc Ott says:

    “It’s not some aggressive counter-ideology looking for a chance to take the reins of culture.”

    Yes it is.

    “It’s a return of stories featuring tough (but likable) dads that deserve some respect and sons that you’d want to see go out and earn it.”

    Yes dads are natural. Yes it speaks to our animal spirits. But lining up a culture with our wild nature first of all IS OF THE WILD and therefor aggressive and second it is a culture.

    Culture is a living thing held by the living. Currently the living live a non-culture culture. It exists it is what is real it is what we live in. Yes we got these old books and memory of our forefathers but that line has been broken. What exists and what we want is counter to the other.

    To reassert it is violent and aggressive and not the original thing. Like the Renaissance picking through the rubble and decaying parchments left by the Romans and Greeks it will never be identical and therefor it is a becoming of a new thing. ie a revolution.

    Note: I’ve been flipping through pages of The Decline of the West…

    I will write things like this because of that. Not asking for forgiveness just making you aware.

    • Jeffro says:

      Man I can’t imagine Brink self-consciously pushing some sort of culture war agenda. It just doesn’t come off that way.

      That this can even remotely be construed as revolutionary is only because other people have been so thorough in their efforts to drive normalcy out of the storytelling.

      • Hooc Ott says:

        “Man I can’t imagine Brink self-consciously pushing some sort of culture war agenda. It just doesn’t come off that way.”

        I don’t think culture is entirely a reasoned thing. And when it comes to an innate aspect of culture like family (dads) it probably isn’t at all. Being an unreasoned thing doesn’t stop it from being cultural, counter or aggressive.

        The destruction of dads is no doubt reasoned and manufactured. Heck just go watch a Youtube video of a Yale professor talking about critical theory and it is spelled out in black and white. “Family is a block to progress so therefor the family is a false consciousness social construct and must be destroyed.”

        One sort of off topic thought is do TV executives writers editors publishers etc sit around talk and plan this? Or are we at a point at which it is Pavlov trained into them to just automatically produce this stuff?

  • BV Larson and Vaughn Heppner are yuuuge indies, in the seven-figure-a-year range, and their adventure/military sci-fi all has manly male leads doing manly things–to the point that they do get some flak from female readers about the lack of depth in their female characters. Yet they sell millions.

    Me, I’ve tried to walk the line between, including strong female protagonists, but not exclusively, as my work tends to be 3PPOV and have more than one protagonist, usually one man, one woman–and I’m selling just fine, thank you.

    The point is, there’s plenty of room for strong men in sci-fi as far as readers are concerned. It’s the publishers and the gatekeepers within that are rigging the game.

    Fortunately, with the digital revolution, indie authors can bypass them.

  • Anthony says:

    Ilya’s father in “Somewhither” came off as pretty strict but well-loved by his son.

  • Dan Wolfgang says:

    I think there’s an error with that John Van Stry link.

  • “nearly non-stop action. It’s straight ahead no-frills military science fiction with alien invaders ” + $1.99 = winning formula.

    (Kind of the anti-Scalzi, now that I think of it.)

    Speaking of Somewhither, anyone know when Nowhither’s coming out? Interested parties would like to know.

  • J. D. Brink says:

    Well damn, fellas. Now you’ve got me psychoanalyzing myself and wondering about my own subconscious agenda!

    A military SF story in “The Scythe of Kronos” has another strong dad thing going on. (Which I didn’t really consciously notice until now…) And I’ve had female readers comment about “Tarnish,” saying it’s very much a male story and they didn’t care for how Wil treated some of the female characters. (But in that case, I think she just didn’t understand some aspects of the young male POV and maybe didn’t catch that there were consequences.)

    However, I do have a lot of very strong female badassery in my superhero stuff.

    You’re driving me to therapy…

    Instead, I’ll just say THANKS for the kind words! (And flattered that I could stir a little debate of any kind.)

    • deuce says:

      Don’t feel abashed about not noticing “the strong dad thing”. That’s how things are supposed to be and often WERE back in the day. We need to get back to the point where such things aren’t an oddity.

  • J. D. Brink says:

    I certainly agree that what I would think would be a predominant aspect of SF—that being a tendency toward action, adventure, excitement—just isn’t what mainstream SF has been for a long, long time. It seems all the magazines only want to print more literary stories. Not that there’s anything wrong with that, but really, ALL of you want that? Isn’t there anyone out there who wants to print more exciting, fun stuff? ‘Cuz all the SFF readers I know want that.

    I think the inklings of this “modern pulp revolution” is just what we need. And in this era where the gatekeepers don’t have absolute power anymore, that’s what we’re going to get.

    Thanks again for the shot in the arm.

  • deuce says:

    “It seems all the magazines only want to print more literary stories.”

    All of those editors are just Mini Me grandchildren of William Dean Howells:

    http://thepulparchvist.blogspot.com/2016/12/what-happened-to-fun.html

  • Now I’m thinking I should start a martial arts school, teaching 300-pound dudes to fight like 90-pound girls.

  • Please give us your valuable comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *