REVIEW: Victorious (The Lost Fleet, Book 6) by Jack Campbell

Thursday , 22, May 2014 1 Comment

coverVictorious is the final book in The Lost Fleet series and one of its best. Given the title, it won’t come as a surprise that the book narrates how Jack Geary finally manages to win the war against the Syndics. But Victorious also leaves some mysteries unsolved and a few lose ends that will be explored in the two following series. One of these follow-up series is about the Syndics and the other about the Enigma aliens.

This book begins with Captain Black Jack Geary finally meeting the Alliance Council to report on his historic mission in Syndic space and to make some proposals on how to put an end to the war.

The Humble Hero

As we’ve seen with so many characters in these books, a number of Council members distrust Geary just because he has the power to do evil so they conclude he must intend evil. Some of them want to arrest him but the quick meeting concludes with a promotion to Fleet Admiral and a new mission to return to the Syndic Worlds. The goals now are two: to end the war against the Syndics and to try to prevent one against the Enigma aliens.

But Black Jack Geary is very much like Horatio Hornblower: loyal, self-sacrificing, and humble to the point that few understand him. He even tries to avoid being promoted, convinced as he is that he doesn’t deserve it.

Actually, the similarities go further. Like the British fictional hero, Black Jack is embarrassingly clueless about women. Being a winner, he attracts them, but he just doesn’t ‘get’ them. Campbell makes it abundantly clear that as soon as this last mission is over, Captain Tanya Desjani and Fleet Admiral Geary will be a couple. At the moment, she is waiting for him on Dauntless, and when he gets backs and she finds out what has happened at the meeting, oh, surprise, surprise, the fantastic news are grounds for… drama! And Campbell closes that sad scene telling us that she requests permission to leave the room and then:

He nodded, feeling immensely tired.“Yes, Captain Desjani. Thank you.”

Compared to trying to deal with Alliance politicians, crushing the Syndics should be a piece of cake, and compared to trying to understand Captain Tanya Desjani, figuring out what the aliens wanted should be easy.

The next time he sees Tanya, she has already found another thing to complain about. And it is up to him to solve it, never mind that she is the captain of the fleet flagship. Now that Tanya knows that she has won the big prize by seizing the alpha male of the galaxy for herself, nothing will make her happy. Nietzsche saidrepeating a joke from those daysthat women were “not even superficial”. In the first five books of the series, Desjani was very much like that: a one-dimensional unconditional supporter of Geary, but now she is chronically unsatisfyable. To compensate, Victoria Rione spends the entire book being nice, reasonable, and even helpful.

Surprises: It’s A Trap! Another Death Star!

Campbell is always reluctant to surprise the reader and the last book of the series would have been an excellent place to dare do just that. Alas, long before the fleet encounters more aliens, a Syndic prisoner gives us a few clues about his evil government and the mysterious aliens of the Enigma Race. And none of those revelations imply any plot twist or shock, they are mostly confirmations of suspicions and additional details to keep worries growing. (In the next three paragraphs there’ll be some huge retro-spoilers: revealing major events from previous books.)

We have already seen how the Syndics turn the jump gates into genocidal weapons. Countless lives have been lost. Irreparable damage done to entire worlds. And there is a very real possibility that this doomsday weapon might be used massively by the Enigma Race against all mankind. Understandably, this is very high in the Geary’s list of concerns. And there have already been a good number of conversations about this. One of the consequences of such conversations has been the development of a “safe-fail mechanism”. Of course, if the owner of the jump gate still wants to use it as a weapon, he can always deactivate the safe-fail.

But when halfway through the book the Syndics try this (again!) it takes our heroes another impromptu brainstorming session to realize what is going on. Preventing this type of catastrophe was one of the very reasons why they were sent on this new mission and yet, it takes them by surprise?! Whiskey Tango Foxtrot!

I understand that the good guys can’t just jump into the system, notice all the hints that the trap is in place and proceed to deactivate it. That would be anticlimactic. It wouldn’t work because it would spoil all the fun and suspense. But this ultra-naiveté doesn’t work either.

After that, the book improves very much. There is plenty of action with the Syndics and the Enigma race complete with hints about things to come in the other series.  

A Proper Ending

As I said before, given the title, we know that the book ends well. And we also have good reason to suspect that the protagonist will have more than one reason to smile at the end. After all those troubles and difficulties, the book ends on a not-so-military high note.

RATING: 7/10

Please give us your valuable comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *