Short Reviews – Defense Mechanism, by Katherine MacLean

Friday , 29, June 2018 1 Comment

Defense Mechanism by Katherine MacLean appeared in the October 1949 issue of Astounding. It can be read here at Archive.org.

Defense Mechanism was tucked behind the book reviews and letters to the editor, so I almost missed it! Considering how influential its writer would go on to be, it’s ironic that her debut could go so easily unnoticed. And as far as stories in Astounding go, this certainly wasn’t the worst.

A writer has an infant/toddler son with empathic telepathy. The father is able to hear his own thoughts and the thoughts of others reflected back from his son. Mother is a bit concerned, particularly since the child is developing slowly, but dad, a bit of an empath himself, went through a similar phase as a late bloomer.

There are quite a lot of literal thinks being thought both at and around characters in this thinky-story. There is, however, an action-packed climax to this thinky-story of many thinks, so it has one-up on at least a couple stories from Astounding I’ve reviewed recently.

Sometimes, the young child makes empathic connection with the rabbits out in the fields outside, and the father enjoys mentally observing/receiving the telepathic impression/connections with his child’s bunny-friend. But father senses something wrong; the rabbit is in distress.

Father goes out to find that a hunter is poaching rabbits; a mental connection that the son relays hits the father like a ton of bricks—the father snaps and kills the hunter, who it turns out was some kind of psychopath.

Defense Mechanism feels oddly familiar. Right down to the rabbit. It’s going to bother me for a while that I can’t remember where I’ve seen it before or why I think I have (empathic telepathy?!). This is the sort of story that would be at home in Thrilling Wonder Stories or Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, but that’s not where I’m remembering it from. Yet, I haven’t read any of the many anthologies in which this story has been reprinted.

MacLean would go on to be fairly prolific throughout the 50s and continued writing for many decades, though without the volume of her 50s output. As far as I can tell, she’s still alive and was interviewed as recently as 2013 for the New York Review of Science Fiction.

Don’t forget! It’s the last days to pre-order Wild Stars III: Time Warmageddon. Don’t miss out, because this will be your only chance to get your hands on copies.

Cover by Tim Lim

One Comment
  • Mark McSherry says:

    There is that humorous story of MacLean and the encounter at the electronics convention- she is confronted for not wearing a badge.

    The anecdote starts at the 4:30 minute mark and runs for four minutes-

    https://www.dcyoutube.com/watch/9swcMDVSYpY

  • Please give us your valuable comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *