Book Review: Sheepfarmer’s Daughter

Sunday , 4, December 2016 5 Comments

fd80e893e7a006b5fb6bf010-lBack in July, I reviewed the military fantasy anthology Shattered Shields. I have mentioned that Elizabeth Moon’s “First Blood” stood out enough that I would search out more.

Continuing education in Cleveland, OH in late October meant that I had to stop at Mac’s Back Paperbacks. I picked up a used copy of Elizabeth Moon’s Sheepfarmer’s Daughter, book one of The Deeds of Paksenarrion.

I remember seeing this book on the shelves at the time. I was not reading much in the way of new fantasy at the time being suspicious of the avalanche bad Tolkien derived fantasy (no offence to J. R. R. himself).

One could be forgiven at the time as the first thing you saw inside the book was this blurb by Judith Tarr:

“This is the first work of high heroic fantasy I’ve seen that has taken the work of Tolkien, assimilated it totally it totally and deeply and absolutely, and produced something altogether new and yet incontestably based on the master…This is the Fourth Age as it has to have been.”

The back cover emphasizes that Elizabeth Moon joined the U.S. Marine Corps in 1968 and completed both Officers Candidate School and Basic School, reaching the rank of 1st Lieutenant during active duty.

Baen Books published Sheepfarmer’s Daughter in July 1988. Price was $3.95, cover painting by Kevin Davies, 506 pages.

The story starts out with Paksenarrion, the sheep farmer’s daughter running away from home to escape an arranged marriage. She joins as a recruit in a mercenary company. The first 40 pages are about training. Moon puts in a lot of detail into the training of raw recruits. Paks as she is known becomes the object of unwanted attention in an incident never fully explained. A veteran attempted to force her sexually and when the guards arrive he is down and she is bloody. A court inquiry clears her of assault charges with two fellow recruits expelled from the company.

Lots of detail is given to the journey south for her first campaign. Paks is wounded in one battle. The next year has a garrison in one fortress forced to surrender to overwhelming forces of a rival mercenary company. Given parole while waiting for ransom, Paks and two others are out gathering berries when the fortification is attacked by the forces of a nefarious character known as the Honeycat.

Paks and her two companions travel south to warn Duke Phelan, commander of the mercenary company. The company races north along with the rival mercenary company to relieve the siege of the fortress.

The rest of the book is the campaign the next year to hunt down the Honeycat and destroy his power. I began to lose some interest after 300 pages. Along the way we find that Paksennarion might be some sort of paladin, given power by a particular god. The Honeycat was a well done character. He was not a near omnipotent dark lord but he was supreme bastard.

Moon’s prose moves along well for the most part. I have been told the second and third books are better as this is the origin story. Moon knows a military unit works. This aspect is better as military fantasy than Glen Cook’s Black Company. The supernatural or magical element is low key. There is some magical healing once in a while.

My big problem with the book is the idea of females fighting in a mercenary company alongside men as if there is no difference. I have laid out my views on fictional femizons. The suspension of disbelief is stretched to the breaking point with female soldiers as good as the men in hand to hand combat. I have issues with the idea of mercenary companies as an elite. As John Cale said, mercenaries are willing to fight for you but not die for you.

So, Moon is a fairly good writer from a technical standpoint. I would give Sheepfarmer’s Daughter a 3 out of 5 harmonic chromosome rating. Will I read the other two books in the series? Time will tell.

5 Comments
  • Hooc Ott says:

    “My big problem with the book is the idea of females fighting in a mercenary company alongside men as if there is no difference.”

    I have a problem with shepherds being called sheep farmers, with a non-royal shepherd’s daughter having her marriage arranged and a tiny bit erked that a shepherd (normally the lowest rung of non-enslaved medieval society) somehow getting a woman to have a child with him at all.

    The books “A World lit Only by Fire” and “Montaillou The Promised Land of Error” really call out how feminist narrative filled dross like this is.

    I suppose the whole arrange marriage thing comes from royalty who sold off their daughters for alliances with neighboring lords.

    But peasants?!?! and running away from it? If anything i am sure good salt of the earth serfs probably brought in boys for visits to seduce a hanger-on daughter just so they get the mouth to feed out of the house and make grandkids for em but that has nothing to do with running away. For goodness sake the parents would literally be trying to make her run away at that point.

    • Terry Sanders says:

      Arranged marriages were the norm for a long time, for all classes. Upper-end marriages tended to be political, while the lower classes focused on economic concerns. (Combining two marginal farms into one that could make a profit was a common one.)

      As late as the Thirties, Dorothy Sayers had the following exchange happen in a village pub:

      BUTTER
      His lordship married for love.

      LOCAL
      Ah, well, I dessay he can afford it.

  • Eric Ashley says:

    The third book has one of the greatest scenes I’ve ever read.

  • Leave a Reply to Hooc Ott Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *